A community for Captain Swan shippers
The great Killian Hair Debate
Alright CSers. I'm going to try to kick start a little flaily debate. What is your favourite Killian hair? Answer and feel free to provide a detailed ranking and discuss in the replies!




I always label his 4a hair as his "responsible suitor" haircut. I love it, actually.
Me too! He looked so handsome in 4a, I mean he always does but yes his hair in 4a (and 4b) was on point!
I struggled so hard with this. Like you wouldn't believe. And while I struggled with choosing between 3b and 4a... I chose DO hair. Because when it comes down to it... That chaotic mess of sin did things to me I could never confess.
chaotic mess of sin is an accurate description
3b hair for me. I don't think he gets much better than how he looked in the CS movie tbh. Yum.
Same here. The CS movie look is definitely my favourite.
This is an unfair question....I love almost every version of his hair.
I feel like BesselY should be putting in her two cents. Can I tag in this platform? @besselY. I guess not? BESSEL COME ARGUE WITH ME!!!!
3B ~ 3A > 2 > Dark Hook > 4B > 5A> 4A > 5B, and where is Lydia when we need her?
No one thinks 3A?? I think Killian's hair always looks its best when he is the pirate bad boy. His change over to the heroes side, and while portraying the ultimate hero, always tames his hair.
His hair looks great in NL, but also once they're back home in SB. Come on, 3x11?? 3A Killian Jones' hair has to be my favorite (with 3B following closely).
Yeah for me 3a comes right after 3b. It's the CS movie that makes me go for 3b as my #1
Loved Dark One Hook hair but my favorite was his 4B look with the neat hair and trimmed scruff and less eyeliner.
oh no, that is my least fav... they tamed the pirate and I was not happy....
I think I like it so much because he is happy.
why can Killian be happy at the same time we are? :curses at ABC:
I love all of his hairstyles equally.
Really? No preference between clean cut vs long bed hair? J'accuse!
I voted 4B, but really! The clean cut look is so great and presentable, but the long hair with flippies is perfect for running hands through. It might be the only dude whose haircuts aren't strange and offputting.
I voted 4a, but I must say it's a combo of hair and Colin nice tan that year...
Do you have a ranking :) ?
Where is the option for all the above? lol
As I've said before... it's not about the length, is about it being untamed!
TIME TO VOTE LENA
I DID... DARK HOOK HAIR FOREVER
It's not showing up in the actual quiz...did you click an option?
Ah I see it now
So ok. What's your ranking?
DO, 5a, 5b/3b (tied), 2 , 3a, 4b, 4a, (in reverse tameness order basically)
I feel like 3a was wilder than 3b
I would call 3A artificially wild but 3 wins as a whole for me
I think you are right Lena. It's all about the "bed "hair. The more messy the better.
I'm gonna have to be honest, 5B hair is not my favourite tho I like them s2 long. My vote goes to 4A freshly cut but it was also pretty cool for the CS movie :)