I Seem to Be Stuck...

I seem to be stuck. I own quite the collection of video games with popular and lesser known titles(Minus some games like GTA), yet i've played everyone one a good bit and don't feel like replaying them. Regrettably, there are some haven't finished but I knew the story well enough to feel like a completionist . I just have such good memory the gameplay seems old. Is there a Specific game that might be able to replay that I could feel a new game each time I played?